Is it possible to pass groups with transactions not to be signed?

[ivnsch]

WalletConnect allows to pass group transactions that are not to be signed by the current user (i.e. only for informative purpose). See e.g tutorial:

const txnsToSign = txns.map(txn => {
  const encodedTxn = Buffer.from(algosdk.encodeUnsignedTransaction(txn.txn)).toString("base64");

  return {
    txn: encodedTxn,
    message: 'Description of transaction being signed',
    // Note: if the transaction does not need to be signed (because it's part of an atomic group
    // that will be signed by another party), specify an empty singers array like so:
    // signers: [],
  };
});

This way it's possible for the user to review all the transactions in the group when signing their part.

Is this possible with My Algo?

[Alex99y]

Hello @ivanschuetz ! No, it isn't possible. MyAlgo Connect only receives the transactions that the user could sign.

[ivnsch]

Okay, I'd like to request this feature. At least for some groups it seems critical, e.g. for an atomic swap, it would make sense to be able to review the tokens you receive before you sign the "send" transaction.

[Alex99y]

@ivanschuetz yes, we are aware of that, but it is really difficult to make this feature with the current implementation. Our long-term plan is to implement ARC-0001 which will easily allow this feature.
https://github.com/algorandfoundation/ARCs/blob/main/ARCs/arc-0001.md

[gidonkatten]

+1 for this feature

[ismael-elatifi]

Yes this feature is very much wanted !
AlgoSigner already supports this :

let signedTxs = await AlgoSigner.signTxn([
  {
    txn: base64Txs[0],
  },
  {
    // This tells AlgoSigner that this transaction is not meant to be signed
    txn: base64Txs[1],
    signers: [],
  },
]);

https://github.com/PureStake/algosigner/blob/develop/docs/dApp-integration.md#atomic-transactions

[webbgeorge]

Hi there! Are there any current plans for this feature to be implemented? @Alex99y does MyAlgo have a public roadmap you can share?

[nkbt]

@webbgeorge

Hi there! Are there any current plans for this feature to be implemented? @Alex99y does MyAlgo have a public roadmap you can share?

You can just pass only unsigned txns from the group, no need to send pre-signed ones. MyAlgo is ok and does not strictly check for group validity (like AlgoSIgner does)