Meetingminutes Minutes05072017

July 05, 2017 Meeting Minutes

Meeting commenced 1:00 PM PST

• Roll call (Tony C.) - quorum achieved

Proposed agenda

• Roll call
• Review / approval of the agenda
• Review of previous meeting minutes (June 07, 2017)
• Congratulate Bruce RIch on OASIS board.
• V3.0 Items (Other business to be covered in the next meeting)
  • • Items from public review comments on 2.40 Erata (Comments: https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/pkcs11/download.php/58032 )
      • Item 12 – make the doc match the header file wrt CK_TLS_MAC_PARAMS (Chris Z)
      • Item 13 - ECDH2 derive params are not in the docs, but in the header file. (Tony C)
      • Item 14 - Definitions of CKK_MD5_HMAC, CKK_RIPEMD128_HMAC and CKK_RIPEMD160_HMAC were merged from draft of v2.30. They were not present in v2.40 and currently are not described in the docs.(TC decided to remove from header file: Bob R)
      • Item 17 – Definitions of CKA_DERIVE_TEMPLATE is completely new in v2.40e1 headers. It was not present in any older version and currently is not described in the docs. This may be a leftover from v2.30 headers (see #2). (Ballot passed - Chris Z)
      • Item 19 - Definitions of CKD_SHA224_KDF, CKD_SHA256_KDF, CKD_SHA384_KDF, CKD_SHA512_KDF and CKD_CPDIVERSIFY_KDF are completely new in v2.40e1 headers. This may be a leftover from v2.30 headers (see #2). (Bob R)
      • Item 21 – CKM_TLS12_KDF is present in headers however it is not described in the docs. provide proposal for the proposed documentation content for header file items noted (Tony C)
  • Additional ECC Curves (Darren J)
  • KMIP Mappings (Tim H)
  • C_LoginUser (Tim H)
  • IPsec Derive (Bob R)
  • Provisioning (Bob R)
  • SP-800-108 - KDF (Darren J)
  • GCM/CCM Errors (David G)
• Call for late arrivals
• Set next meeting date
• Adjourn

Motion to approve Agenda

• Tim moved. Gerry seconded. No objections, comments or abstentions. Motion approved.

Motion to approve meeting minutes

• June 07, 2017
• Tim made a slight modification to expand Tony's shorthand about updating the wiki.
• Tim moved. Gerry seconded. No objections, comments or abstentions. Minutes approved.

Congratulate Bruce Rich

• Congratulations, Bruce, for being elected to the OASIS board!

V3.0

Items from public review comments on 2.40 Errata 01 that TC wanted to try to take action on for 3.0 - proposals required.

• Comments: https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/pkcs11/download.php/58032 )

Item 12 – make the doc match the header file wrt CK_TLS_MAC_PARAMS (Chris Z)

• deferred

Item 13 - ECDH2 derive params are not in the docs, but in the header file. (Tony C)

• deferred

Item 14 - Definitions of CKK_MD5_HMAC, CKK_RIPEMD128_HMAC and CKK_RIPEMD160_HMAC were merged from draft of v2.30. They were not present in v2.40 and currently are not described in the docs.(TC decided to remove from header file: Bob R)

• deferred

Item 17 Definitions of CKA_DERIVE_TEMPLATE is completely new in v2.40e1 headers. It was not present in any older version and currently is not described in the docs. This may be a leftover from v2.30 headers (see #2). (Ballot passed - Chris Z)

• deferred

Item 19 – Definitions of CKD_SHA224_KDF, CKD_SHA256_KDF, CKD_SHA384_KDF, CKD_SHA512_KDF and CKD_CPDIVERSIFY_KDF are completely new in v2.40e1 headers. This may be a leftover from v2.30 headers (see #2). (Bob R)

• deferred

Item 21 - CKM_TLS12_KDF is present in headers however it is not described in the docs. provide proposal for the proposed documentation content for header file items noted (Tony C)

• deferred

Additional ECC Curves (Darren J)

• It should be a small amount of text, but missed the TC deadlines. Should we defer to 3.1?
• Tony: Can we do this in the time frame we need still to close the remaining required items?
• Valerie: TC approved a schedule in February face-to-face to have a committee spec draft by July
• Tony: We've filtered in May what proposals are in and which ones are out, proposing re-reviewing time line and proposals we decided as a TC were in. Any objections to that approach? Valerie noted that it will be difficult to make progress in the summer. Tony noted editors are also on vacation, our plans may have been too ambitious.

KMIP Mappings (Tim H)

• no updates.

C_LoginUser (Tim H)

• pending update to wiki.

IPsec Derive (Bob R)

• deferred

Provisioning (Bob R)

• deferred

SP-800-108 - KDF (Darren J)

• posted latest updates to reflector based on Dieter's and another's views. Darren is still looking for comments. Tim hasn't had a chance to review, yet. TC should review by next week, move to approve in next meeting.

GCM/CCM Errors (David G)

• deferred

Call for late arrivals

• 1 late arrival (Jeff)

Next meeting

• 19 July 2017.

Motion to Adjourn

• Greg moved. Gerry seconded. No objections, comments or abstentions. Motion approved.

Meeting Adjourned at 1:29 PM PST