-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 27
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Refactor Documentation Generation: Transition from Mermaid to Code2Flow #27
base: main
Are you sure you want to change the base?
Conversation
- Reintroduced code2flow for flowchart generation, replacing previous Mermaid diagram implementation. - Adjusted create_module_documentation function to generate flowcharts with code2flow for individual modules. - Modified generate_flow_chart_for_system to utilize code2flow for creating a system-wide flowchart. - Removed functions and logic related to Mermaid diagram generation and validation, aligning with the shift back to code2flow. - Updated script comments and logging to reflect changes in flowchart generation methodology. - Removed Old Prompts related to Mermaid
Modified the code2flow command calls in both the generate_flow_chart and generate_flow_chart_for_system functions to include several additional options: --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors. These enhancements aim to improve the detail and clarity of the generated flowcharts while also providing more verbose output for better debugging and skipping parse errors to ensure smoother execution.
…tion Enhanced the check_tools_and_files function to include validations for the presence of code2flow and Graphviz's dot command. This update ensures that all necessary dependencies for flowchart generation are available before script execution, thus preventing runtime errors related to missing tools. Included are user-friendly installation instructions for these tools, enhancing the robustness and user experience of the setup process.
- Updated the 'Visualization' section in README to reflect the transition from Mermaid.js to Code2Flow for flowchart generation. Removed all mentions of Mermaid CLI and associated features, focusing exclusively on Code2Flow capabilities. - Revised the 'Prerequisites' section to replace `mermaidcli` installation instructions with `Code2Flow`. - Adjusted the 'Supported Languages' section to include specific languages supported by Code2Flow along with their dependencies. - Removed Mermaid-related prompt files from the 'Prerequisites' list, aligning with the shift to Code2Flow. - Updated the 'Known Issues and Solutions' section by removing references to Mermaid diagram syntax issues, focusing on ongoing improvements and user experience enhancements. - Ensured consistency throughout the README to reflect the updated flowchart generation methodology and tool requirements.
Finishing touches to the Readme on the transition to Code2Flow for Flowmap creation.
Haha good to see my PR meets GPT4 level acceptance, especially considering
all the syntax issues with utilizing mermaid js.
We tried to grow the documentation agent too fast and I didn’t stay long
enough to iteratively refine out the issues.
That was my last PR before being let go and would be much happier leaving
it in a better working state.
…On Wed, Jan 24, 2024 at 11:36 AM Kelvin Amoaba ***@***.***> wrote:
PR Analysis
- *Main theme:* Transition from Mermaid to Code2Flow for flowchart
generation
- *PR summary:* This PR transitions the documentation generator tool
from using Mermaid for flowchart generation to using Code2Flow, with the
goal of improving clarity and capabilities.
- *Type of PR:* Enhancement
- *Score <https://docs.bito.ai>(0-100, higher is better):* 95
- *Relevant tests added:* False
- *Estimated effort to review <https://docs.bito.ai>(1-5, lower is
better):* 3 The changes are relatively straightforward conceptually,
but there are a number of files and integrations to validate.
PR Feedback
- *General suggestions:* Overall this PR represents a nice improvement
in the tool's visualization capabilities. The Code2Flow integration seems
well done based on the code changes. No major issues identified. As
Code2Flow matures, it may be useful to revisit and leverage any new
features added.
Code feedback file: documentation/create_overview_doc/README.md
- *Suggestions:*
1. Consider adding details on specific Code2Flow dependencies for each
language to the README [important] *Relevant line*:In
documentation/create_overview_doc/README.md at line 59
- JavaScript: Requires Acorn for parsing. Ensure Acorn is installed and accessible in your environment.
file: documentation/create_overview_doc/createdoc.sh
- *Suggestions:*
1. Well structured use of functions to encapsulate logic *Relevant
line*:In documentation/create_overview_doc/createdoc.sh at line 16
function bito_response_ok() {
1. Good validation check for required tools and files *Relevant line*:In
documentation/create_overview_doc/createdoc.sh at line 34
function check_tools_and_files() {
—
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
<#27 (comment)>,
or unsubscribe
<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AJ5ZMPSD455AWP5UG4HIQZDYQFPFDAVCNFSM6AAAAABAHC2JM2VHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMYTSMBYG44TGMZRGM>
.
You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID:
***@***.***>
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Review comments
Code Review Agent Run Status
Code Review Overview
High-level FeedbackConsider refactoring the code into smaller, modular functions to improve maintainability and readability. Implement input validation and sanitization to enhance security. Use consistent formatting and list markers in documentation to avoid rendering issues. Transition to using containerization or separate scripts for environment setup to improve reproducibility and manage dependencies more effectively. Detailed code Feedbackfile: Colab-TextGen-GPU.ipynb
file: documentation/create_overview_doc/README.md
|
Code Review Agent Run Status
|
Code Review Agent Run Status
Code Review Overview
>>See detailed code suggestions<< High-level FeedbackEnsure thorough testing of new features and maintain clear, comprehensive documentation to facilitate future updates and usage. |
Code Review Agent Run Status
Code Review Overview
>>See detailed code suggestions<< High-level FeedbackConsider implementing conditional logic and environment-based configurations to optimize performance and security. Validate and sanitize inputs for new flags in Code2Flow to prevent security risks. Ensure dependencies are up-to-date and consider lazy loading to enhance performance. Streamline configuration options to balance flexibility with performance, and manage unsupported languages gracefully to avoid process failures. |
- **Visualization with Code2Flow**: AI-generated visual flow maps to represent module interactions, configured with flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors for optimal detail and clarity. | ||
|
||
- **Code2Flow CLI Image Conversion**: The tool uses Code2Flow for creating detailed flow maps, offering a clear visual representation of your code architecture. | ||
- **Customizable Flowchart Generation: Code2Flow** Configured with flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors to optimize the detail and clarity of flowcharts.** |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Security Issue: The integration of Code2Flow in the documentation generation process introduces potential security risks if the flags and configurations are not properly validated. The use of flags such as --no-trimming and --verbose could inadvertently expose sensitive information or system details through the generated documentation if not handled securely.
Fix: Implement input validation for the flags and configurations used in Code2Flow to ensure that only safe and intended modifications are allowed. This could involve sanitizing inputs to remove potentially harmful options or validating against a list of allowed flags.
Code Suggestion:
- Visualization with Code2Flow: AI-generated visual flow maps to represent module interactions, configured with flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors for optimal detail and clarity.
+ Visualization with Code2Flow: AI-generated visual flow maps to represent module interactions, configured with validated flags for optimal detail and clarity.
- JavaScript: Requires Acorn for parsing. Ensure Acorn is installed and accessible in your environment. | ||
- Ruby: Uses Parser for parsing. Ensure the Parser gem is installed and accessible. | ||
- PHP: Employs PHP-Parser for parsing. PHP-Parser should be installed and accessible in your environment. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Security Issue: The code introduces potential security risks by assuming that dependencies like Acorn, Parser, and PHP-Parser are installed without verifying their presence or versions. This could lead to execution with outdated or vulnerable versions of these dependencies.
Fix: Implement checks to verify that the required dependencies are installed and up-to-date before proceeding with their usage.
Code Suggestion:
+if ! npm list -g acorn; then npm install -g acorn@latest; fi
+if ! gem list -i parser; then gem install parser; fi
+if ! php -m | grep -q 'PHP-Parser'; then pecl install PHP-Parser; fi
- **Visualization with Code2Flow**: AI-generated visual flow maps to represent module interactions, configured with flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors for optimal detail and clarity. | ||
|
||
- **Code2Flow CLI Image Conversion**: The tool uses Code2Flow for creating detailed flow maps, offering a clear visual representation of your code architecture. | ||
- **Customizable Flowchart Generation: Code2Flow** Configured with flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors to optimize the detail and clarity of flowcharts.** |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Scalability Issue: The introduction of Code2Flow with additional flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors may introduce scalability concerns due to increased complexity and potential processing overhead. These options could lead to more intensive computation and memory usage, especially with large codebases.
Fix: Consider implementing conditional logic to enable these detailed features only when necessary, or provide configuration options to adjust the level of detail based on the system's capacity and expected load.
Code Suggestion:
+ if (systemCapacity >= HIGH_CAPACITY) {
+ configureCode2Flow(--hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, --skip-parse-errors);
+ } else {
+ configureCode2Flow();
+ }
- JavaScript: Requires Acorn for parsing. Ensure Acorn is installed and accessible in your environment. | ||
- Ruby: Uses Parser for parsing. Ensure the Parser gem is installed and accessible. | ||
- PHP: Employs PHP-Parser for parsing. PHP-Parser should be installed and accessible in your environment. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Scalability Issue: The addition of language-specific dependencies for Code2Flow might introduce scalability issues if not managed properly. Each language parser (Acorn for JavaScript, Parser gem for Ruby, PHP-Parser for PHP) increases the complexity and potential overhead during the documentation generation process. This could lead to increased memory usage and slower processing times, especially with large codebases or multiple concurrent documentation generation processes.
Fix: Consider implementing a lazy loading mechanism or an on-demand initialization of these parsers only when a specific language is detected in the project being documented. This approach minimizes the memory footprint and initialization overhead by loading resources only when necessary.
Code Suggestion:
+if project_languages.include? 'JavaScript'
+ require 'acorn'
+end
+if project_languages.include? 'Ruby'
+ require 'parser'
+end
+if project_languages.include? 'PHP'
+ require 'php-parser'
+end
- **Visualization with Code2Flow**: AI-generated visual flow maps to represent module interactions, configured with flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors for optimal detail and clarity. | ||
|
||
- **Code2Flow CLI Image Conversion**: The tool uses Code2Flow for creating detailed flow maps, offering a clear visual representation of your code architecture. | ||
- **Customizable Flowchart Generation: Code2Flow** Configured with flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors to optimize the detail and clarity of flowcharts.** |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Performance Issue: The integration of Code2Flow with additional flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors might lead to increased computational overhead and potential performance bottlenecks due to the verbose output and no trimming options. These settings can significantly increase the amount of data processed and stored, impacting the performance of the documentation generation tool.
Fix: Consider implementing conditional flags or environment-based configurations that enable detailed logging and no trimming only during development or debugging sessions. For production usage, default settings should favor performance with minimal verbosity and enabled trimming to reduce the load.
Code Suggestion:
- Visualization with Code2Flow: AI-generated visual flow maps to represent module interactions, configured with flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors for optimal detail and clarity.
+ Visualization with Code2Flow: AI-generated visual flow maps to represent module interactions, configured with environment-based flags to optimize detail and clarity while maintaining performance.
- JavaScript: Requires Acorn for parsing. Ensure Acorn is installed and accessible in your environment. | ||
- Ruby: Uses Parser for parsing. Ensure the Parser gem is installed and accessible. | ||
- PHP: Employs PHP-Parser for parsing. PHP-Parser should be installed and accessible in your environment. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Performance Issue: The addition of language-specific dependencies for Code2Flow might introduce performance bottlenecks if these dependencies are not optimized or if they introduce significant overhead during the flow map generation process.
Fix: Ensure that the dependencies such as Acorn for JavaScript, Parser gem for Ruby, and PHP-Parser are optimized for performance. Consider lazy loading these dependencies or using alternative lightweight libraries if performance issues are detected.
Code Suggestion:
+Ensure that the dependencies such as Acorn for JavaScript, Parser gem for Ruby, and PHP-Parser are optimized for performance. Consider lazy loading these dependencies or using alternative lightweight libraries if performance issues are detected.
- **Visualization with Code2Flow**: AI-generated visual flow maps to represent module interactions, configured with flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors for optimal detail and clarity. | ||
|
||
- **Code2Flow CLI Image Conversion**: The tool uses Code2Flow for creating detailed flow maps, offering a clear visual representation of your code architecture. | ||
- **Customizable Flowchart Generation: Code2Flow** Configured with flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors to optimize the detail and clarity of flowcharts.** |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Optimization Issue: The introduction of multiple flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors in the Code2Flow CLI might lead to increased complexity and potential performance overhead. Each flag potentially adds additional processing layers or disables optimizations, which could affect the performance of the flowchart generation, especially in larger projects.
Fix: Evaluate the necessity of each flag in the context of typical use cases. If certain flags are seldom used or significantly impact performance, consider providing a more streamlined default configuration with optional flags that can be enabled as needed. This approach balances flexibility with performance.
Code Suggestion:
- **Visualization with Code2Flow**: AI-generated visual flow maps to represent module interactions, configured with flags such as --hide-legend, --no-trimming, --verbose, and --skip-parse-errors for optimal detail and clarity.
+ **Visualization with Code2Flow**: AI-generated visual flow maps to represent module interactions. Default settings optimized for performance with optional flags for detailed configuration.
- JavaScript: Requires Acorn for parsing. Ensure Acorn is installed and accessible in your environment. | ||
- Ruby: Uses Parser for parsing. Ensure the Parser gem is installed and accessible. | ||
- PHP: Employs PHP-Parser for parsing. PHP-Parser should be installed and accessible in your environment. | ||
- Python: No additional dependencies are required for Python projects. | ||
|
||
If your project uses a language not supported by Code2Flow for flow map generation, the documentation generation capabilities will still be available, but without the flow map visualization for those specific languages. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Optimization Issue: The implementation details for language support in Code2Flow are mentioned, but there is no error handling for unsupported languages which could lead to failures or unhandled exceptions during the documentation generation process.
Fix: Implement error handling to manage cases where the project uses an unsupported language. This could involve skipping the flow map generation for those languages with a clear log message or providing a fallback mechanism.
Code Suggestion:
+if [ ! supported_languages.contains($language) ]; then
+ echo "Warning: Language $language is not supported for flow map generation. Skipping..."
+ continue
+fi
/review |
Code Review Agent Run Status
Code Review Overview
>>See detailed code suggestions<< See other commands you can run High-level FeedbackEnsure clarity in the installation and setup instructions for new dependencies in the README to prevent user confusion. Consider adding explicit commands for different operating systems to facilitate a smoother setup process. |
For flow map generation with Code2Flow, the tool currently supports the following languages, each with specific dependencies: | ||
|
||
- JavaScript: Requires Acorn for parsing. Ensure Acorn is installed and accessible in your environment. | ||
- Ruby: Uses Parser for parsing. Ensure the Parser gem is installed and accessible. | ||
- PHP: Employs PHP-Parser for parsing. PHP-Parser should be installed and accessible in your environment. | ||
- Python: No additional dependencies are required for Python projects. | ||
|
||
If your project uses a language not supported by Code2Flow for flow map generation, the documentation generation capabilities will still be available, but without the flow map visualization for those specific languages. | ||
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Issue: The addition of language-specific dependency information for Code2Flow is useful but lacks clarity on how to install these dependencies. This could lead to confusion or errors during setup by end-users.
Fix: Provide explicit commands or steps on how to install each mentioned dependency for different operating systems or environments. This will ensure users can easily set up their environment without needing to search for installation instructions elsewhere.
Code Suggestion:
+For flow map generation with Code2Flow, the tool currently supports the following languages, each with specific dependencies:
+- JavaScript: Requires Acorn for parsing. Install it using 'npm install acorn -g'.
+- Ruby: Uses Parser for parsing. Install it using 'gem install parser'.
+- PHP: Employs PHP-Parser for parsing. Install it using 'composer require nikic/php-parser'.
+- Python: No additional dependencies are required for Python projects.
/review |
Code Review Agent Run Status
|
/review |
Code Review Agent Run Status
|
/review |
Code Review Agent Run Status
|
Title:
Description:
This pull request encompasses a series of changes that collectively shift the flowchart generation methodology in our High-Level Documentation Generator from Mermaid.js to Code2Flow. These changes enhance the tool's capabilities in generating more detailed and clearer visual representations of code architecture and improve overall functionality and user experience. Below is a summary of the key updates included in this pull request:
Revert Flowchart Implementation from Mermaid to Code2Flow:
Enhanced Flowchart Generation with Additional Code2Flow Options:
--hide-legend
,--no-trimming
,--verbose
, and--skip-parse-errors
) to optimize the detail and clarity of the generated flowcharts.Added Checks for Code2Flow and Graphviz in check_tools_and_files Function:
dot
command. This ensures all necessary dependencies are in place for successful script execution.Refactor README for Code2Flow Integration and Remove Mermaid References:
These changes collectively represent a significant enhancement to our documentation generation tool, providing more advanced and flexible flowchart generation capabilities while maintaining the tool's ease of use and comprehensive documentation output.